Rent vs Buy Calculator

Last updated:

Break-even point
—

Renting versus buying isn't a lifestyle debate — it's a math problem with a date on it. This rent vs buy calculator compares every dollar of renting (with rent rising each year) against every dollar of buying: mortgage payments, tax, insurance, maintenance, the equity you build, and what your down payment could have earned if you'd invested it instead. The headline answer is your break-even year — the year buying starts winning.

How to use this rent vs buy calculator

Everything recalculates as you type. Here's what each input means.

The verdict line names your break-even year (or tells you renting wins for the whole horizon). Below it: total rent paid, net buying cost, and how far ahead buying finishes — plus a year-by-year table so you can see the lead change hands.

Worked example

Example — $2,000 rent vs a $400,000 home: Rent starts at $2,000/month and climbs 3% a year. The home costs $400,000 with $80,000 down, a 6.5% 30-year mortgage ($2,022.62/month P&I), $4,800/year tax, $1,800/year insurance, 1% maintenance, 3% appreciation, and the down payment could earn 7% invested. Over 10 years: buying breaks even in year 4. By year 10 you've paid $275,133 in cumulative rent versus a $247,034 net buying cost — buying finishes $28,099 ahead, with about $266,283 in home equity built. In year 1, though, renting was still $1,015 cheaper — the down payment and closing years are always renting's best window.

How the math works

The calculator runs two ledgers, year by year, then compares them.

The renting ledger is simple: each year's rent is last year's rent grown by your rent-increase percent, and the running total is just the sum. No equity, no maintenance, no surprises.

The buying ledger has four moving parts:

The break-even year is the first year that net buying cost drops below cumulative rent. Every SialTV Money calculator page documents its own formulas.

Common mistakes and tips

Frequently asked questions

Is renting really throwing money away?
Not necessarily. Rent buys you housing with no maintenance bills, no property tax, and no down payment locked up — and the down payment you didn't spend can be invested. This calculator puts numbers on both sides instead of slogans: it compares cumulative rent against the true net cost of buying, including what your down payment could have earned elsewhere.
What is the break-even year?
The first year when the net cost of buying drops below the total rent you would have paid by then. Before that year, renting was cheaper overall; after it, buying pulls ahead. It is the single most useful number in the rent-vs-buy debate because it turns 'someday' into a date.
Why do you subtract equity from the buying cost?
Because equity is money you get back. If you sell, the home's value minus your remaining loan balance comes back to you (before selling costs). Counting every mortgage payment as 'cost' while ignoring the equity it built would make buying look far worse than it is.
What is the opportunity cost of the down payment?
The growth you give up by locking that cash into a house instead of investing it. At 7% a year, an $80,000 down payment could have become about $157,000 in 10 years — roughly $77,000 of forgone growth. Honest comparisons count it; most back-of-envelope ones don't.
Does this include closing costs?
No — closing costs (often 2–5% of the price) are a real buying expense this tool doesn't model, so mentally add them to the buying side. That means the true break-even year is usually a little later than shown.
How sensitive is the answer to home appreciation?
Very. Appreciation builds your equity, which directly lowers the net buying cost. If you set appreciation to 0%, break-even moves years later; at 5% it arrives much sooner. Use a conservative number — past appreciation is not a promise.