Rent vs Buy Calculator
Last updated:
Year-by-year comparison
| Year | Rent paid (total) | Buying cost (net) | Buying ahead by |
|---|
Renting versus buying isn't a lifestyle debate — it's a math problem with a date on it. This rent vs buy calculator compares every dollar of renting (with rent rising each year) against every dollar of buying: mortgage payments, tax, insurance, maintenance, the equity you build, and what your down payment could have earned if you'd invested it instead. The headline answer is your break-even year — the year buying starts winning.
How to use this rent vs buy calculator
Everything recalculates as you type. Here's what each input means.
- Monthly rent ($) and annual rent increase (%): what you pay now, and how fast you expect it to climb. Defaults: $2,000 and 3%.
- Home price ($) and down payment ($): the house you're comparing against, and the cash you'd put down. Defaults: $400,000 and $80,000.
- Mortgage rate (% APR) and loan term: the loan you'd take. Defaults: 6.5%, 30 years.
- Property tax and home insurance (per year): your local estimates — they vary a lot, so use real numbers. Defaults: $4,800 and $1,800.
- Maintenance (% of home value / year): repairs and upkeep. The classic rule of thumb is 1% of the home's value per year — applied here to the home's growing value.
- Home appreciation (% / year): how fast the home's value grows. Be conservative — 3% is a common planning figure, not a forecast.
- Down payment could earn (% / year): the return you'd expect if that cash stayed invested instead. Default 7%, a common long-run planning figure for a stock-heavy portfolio.
- Compare over (years): your time horizon — how long you expect to stay. Default 10 years.
The verdict line names your break-even year (or tells you renting wins for the whole horizon). Below it: total rent paid, net buying cost, and how far ahead buying finishes — plus a year-by-year table so you can see the lead change hands.
Worked example
How the math works
The calculator runs two ledgers, year by year, then compares them.
The renting ledger is simple: each year's rent is last year's rent grown by your rent-increase percent, and the running total is just the sum. No equity, no maintenance, no surprises.
The buying ledger has four moving parts:
- Cash out: the down payment up front, then each year's actual mortgage payments (principal + interest from a real amortization schedule), property tax, insurance, and maintenance charged as a percent of that year's appreciated home value.
- Equity built: the home's appreciated value minus the remaining loan balance. This is money you'd recover on a sale, so it's subtracted from the cost.
- Opportunity cost: what the down payment would have grown to at your invested-return rate, minus the down payment itself. An $80,000 down payment at 7% costs about $77,000 of forgone growth over 10 years.
- Net buying cost = cash out − equity + opportunity cost.
The break-even year is the first year that net buying cost drops below cumulative rent. Every SialTV Money calculator page documents its own formulas.
Common mistakes and tips
- Comparing rent to PITI only. The mortgage payment isn't the cost of owning — maintenance, the opportunity cost of the down payment, and (subtracted) equity all move the answer by tens of thousands. This calculator counts all of them.
- Assuming rent stays flat. At 3% annual increases, $2,000 rent becomes $2,614 in year 10. Flat-rent math flatters renting.
- Assuming appreciation stays high. Break-even is very sensitive to this input — cut it to 0% and watch the break-even year slide later. Plan conservatively.
- Forgetting closing costs. This tool doesn't model them (typically 2–5% of price), so the real break-even lands a bit later than shown — especially painful if you might move in under 5 years.
- Ignoring the time horizon. Over 3 years, renting usually wins because buying's upfront costs dominate. Over 10+, buying usually wins because equity compounds. Set the horizon to your honest moving plans.
- Treating the verdict as advice. The math can't price flexibility, job mobility, or how much you value not fixing a roof. Use the break-even year as one input to the decision, not the decision.